Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Wyomissing: Authentic Coal-Fired Pizza & Wings in PA
Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza & Wings in Wyomissing delivers an authentic coal-fired pizza experience that impresses from first bite. The hand-tossed dough bakes over high heat, resulting in a perfectly charred, crispy crust with a smoky depth rare to find outside New York. Their wings, caramelized onions, and house-made meatballs offer rich, bold flavors that complement the pizza beautifully. The inviting bar and spacious, clean dining area create a welcoming atmosphere, while attentive staff provide thoughtful touches like warm welcomes and generous samples. Quick service and reasonable prices complete the experience, making Anthony’s a standout spot for genuine, flavorful pizza and more.
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Wyomissing at a glance
- Address 2733 Paper Mill Rd, Wyomissing, PA 19610, United States
- Phone +1 610-816-5722
- Restaurant type Pizza restaurant , Caterer , Chicken wings restaurant , Italian restaurant , Pasta shop , Pizza delivery , Pizza takeaway .
- Popular for Lunch , Dinner , Solo dining .
Photos & Gallery
Popular Menu Items
Eggplant Marino
Kids Pepperoni Pizza
Tuna
Spaghetti
Maria's Meatballs with Ricotta
Meat Pizza
Chopped Salad
Square Margherita Pizza
Spinach & Artichoke Dip
Burnt Bread Came with Salad
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Wyomissing: Reviews & Ratings
I was in tonight as a first time guest. I started at take out to inquire about how I could get a drink but also take a pizza home. Julia greeted me with a smile and suggested I go to the bar where I was met with Karli. I had the best beverage and was given a take out menu to insure I come back again. My pizza was still delicious when I got home.
When you think of pizza places on a strip mall you kind of think the food won’t be so good. That’s not the case with Anthony’s. They were pretty full but we were greeted and sat right away. They provided us with a sampling of their meatballs and marinara sauce and carmelized onion wings since it was our first visit. They were very tasty. We ordered a pepperoni pizza. FROM THE TIME WE ORDERED UNTIL WE GOT OUT FOOD IT WAS A MATTER OF TEN MINUTES. I must say that never happened. Not even with least food places around here. The pizza was made to order and had an excellent taste. I was shocked when I asked for oregano for it and was told they didn’t have any. I was also shocked not seeing any salt and pepper on the table. From someone who seasons everything they eat before they eat it I must say, the pizza didn’t need anything additional. It was perfect as is. The prices were reasonable and the restrooms were very big. The location is like I said in a strip mall so parking is free and limited though. There are handicapped spaces but those are limited too as there are other stores right where Anthony’s is located.
We won a gift card that Anthony's donated to a local fundraiser event, and enjoyed a great family meal. The pizza is delicious We also had great garlic knots and love that they do family sized salads to share.
Mouth watering menu, clean and very open dining experience with a gorgeous bar. If it's your first time they bring you a meatball with fresh made cheese and 2 huge wings with sauteed onions. Absolutely delicious!! Their pizzas are such a unique blend of spices, fresh ingredients and hand made dough. This place is truly a must try!
My wife and I made a spontaneous decision to have lunch and decided to give Anthony’s Coal Fire Pizza a try. Being born and raised in Brooklyn, NY—home to some of the most famous pizzas—I have high standards. But Anthony’s Coal Fire Pizza exceeded my expectations! The atmosphere was fantastic, the service was excellent, and the pizza was outstanding. We ordered an 8-slice pie topped with pepperoni and bacon. It’s been a while since I’ve had my fingertips stained black from the perfectly charred, crunchy crust.
The food was incredible. Perfectly cook crust topping galore and a selection out of this world. The place was very clean and if you want to sit at the bar. I would say it would be a great experience. Small thing is are waitress was not having a good day i would guess
First timer to Anthony's and first coal fired pizza experience. I really enjoyed my evening here. I waa very pleased that oktoberfest was still on tap, service was good. I really liked the Carnivore and my eyes were definitely bigger than my stomach. The flavors of this pizza were very good and I can hardly wait to eat the leftovers. Got to chat it up with two couples at the bar and it really made me feel welcome and stay longer. I definitely would check out the food here if you haven't. Salds looked great, wings looked super tasty but I stuck with my personal favorite mear pizza and it did not disappoint me. Come through, check it out.
I had a fantastic experience! Julia greeted me with a smile when I picked up my takeout order. Karli at the bar was also amazing; she walked me through so many great food and drink options. I'm definitely coming back. The food was good, but the service was even better!
Location
-
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Wyomissing2733 Paper Mill Rd, Wyomissing, PA 19610, United States Hotline: +1 610-816-5722
Located on Paper Mill Road in Wyomissing, Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings offers a distinctive pizza experience that effortlessly combines tradition with innovation. This spot is not your typical strip mall eatery — it surprises with a genuinely warm atmosphere and a menu that caters to a broad range of tastes, from the classic meat pizzas to inventive options like the Cauliflower Pizza and Tomato Basil Pie.
What immediately stands out is the coal-fired cooking method, which delivers a perfectly crisp, slightly charred crust that locks in bold flavors. Customers rave about the unique blend of spices and the freshness of the handmade dough, a testament to their dedication to authentic preparation. The Square Margherita Pizza and the Eggplant Marino are shining examples of how simple ingredients can be transformed into extraordinary dishes when expertly executed.
Anthony's also excels at wings, especially their Coal Fired Chicken Wings and Garlic Romano Wings, which come with a delightful char and robust seasoning. First-time guests are often treated to a sample of their signature wings accompanied by savory meatballs with homemade ricotta, a gesture that speaks to the restaurant’s commitment to hospitality and quality.
Beyond pizza and wings, the menu features hearty options like Spaghetti and Penne Wraps, as well as fresh salads such as the Chopped Salad and family-sized portions that enhance the communal dining experience. The Burnt Bread served with salad adds a rustic charm and depth that complements the meal. For those with dietary considerations, the availability of Cauliflower Pizza offers a lighter yet satisfying alternative without compromising flavor.
Reviews consistently highlight not only the delectable food but also the efficient service and inviting setting, including a spacious bar area that enhances the overall dining ambiance. Whether dining in or ordering takeout, customers appreciate the attention to detail, from the quick prep times to the thoughtful drink pairings suggested by the friendly staff.
In essence, Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings in Wyomissing stands out as a must-visit for anyone seeking quality, character, and a touch of authentic coal-fired charm. The interplay of perfectly charred crusts, fresh ingredients, and a welcoming atmosphere makes every visit memorable and every bite a true pleasure.
Business Information
- Accessibility
- Wheelchair-accessible car park
- Wheelchair-accessible entrance
- Wheelchair-accessible seating
- Wheelchair-accessible toilet
- Service options
- Outdoor seating
- Kerbside pickup
- No-contact delivery
- Delivery
- On-site services
- Takeaway
- Dine-in
- Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards